Don't Let Your Parent's Medicare Plan Auto-Renew Without This Check
Somewhere in your parent's house, probably in a kitchen drawer between the takeout menus and a flashlight that no longer works, there is an envelope marked "Important Plan Information." It showed up by the end of September. It has not been opened. It looks exactly like the junk mail it keeps company with.
That envelope is the Annual Notice of Change, and it is the most useful piece of mail your parent will get all year. Families usually find us asking does Medicare cover assisted living, and the answer there is mostly no. But what Medicare does cover, and what it costs, gets quietly rearranged every autumn. The window to respond to that rearranging opens October 15.
Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15 through December 7, 2026, and any changes take effect January 1, 2027. If your parent does nothing, their current plan renews automatically, along with whatever that plan has changed for next year. A thirty-minute review now is the cheapest insurance you will buy all year.
The Mistake Hiding in Plain Sight
The most common open enrollment mistake is not choosing the wrong plan. It is not choosing at all.
A plan can keep the same name, the same logo, and the same friendly phone number while it swaps a medication to a pricier tier, drops a pharmacy from its preferred list, or trims its network of doctors. Nothing in the mail will feel urgent. Your parent will find out in January, at the pharmacy counter, with a line forming behind them.
So treat the next few weeks like a small annual audit. Four checks cover nearly everything that matters.
Step One: Start With the Prescriptions
Pull out every medication your parent takes, with the dose, and put them in one list. Include the inhalers, eye drops, and the supplement the cardiologist said was fine. If keeping that list straight is already a struggle, our guide to managing a parent's medications is a good companion to this step.
Then check each drug against next year's plan: Is it still covered? Did it move to a higher tier? Does it now need prior authorization? And is your parent's pharmacy still a preferred one?
Know the big numbers, too. For 2027, the standard Part D deductible rises from $615 to $700, and the out-of-pocket threshold moves from $2,100 to $2,400, according to Becker's Hospital Review. Once a person reaches that threshold, covered drugs cost them nothing for the rest of the year. Two details trip families up. Individual plans can charge less than the standard deductible, so the plan in your parent's envelope may differ. And the monthly premium never counts toward the threshold.
Step Two: Confirm the Doctors Are Still In-Network
A directory listing is a promise that can lag behind reality. For every doctor your parent sees regularly, including the specialists, call the office and ask whether they will accept the 2027 plan by name. Do the same for the hospital your parent would actually be taken to, and for any home health agency or therapy provider in the picture.
Pay attention to the rules around the doctors, too. Does the plan require referrals to see a specialist? Does it want approval before certain tests? Those details shape how easy or hard care feels month to month.
If your parent has several conditions and a growing stack of specialists, this is also a good moment to ask whether to choose a geriatrician who can coordinate everything. Plans differ on how they treat that kind of primary care, so check before you commit.
Step Three: Compare the Whole Cost, Not the Premium
Premiums are the loudest number and the least complete one. Many Medicare Advantage plans advertise a $0 monthly premium, but members still pay the Part B premium, and the plan's real cost shows up in other places: copays for specialists, daily hospital charges, drug tiers, and the plan's maximum out-of-pocket limit, which is the most your parent could pay in a bad year.
Run a simple test. Picture the year your parent actually had, with the ER visit, the two specialist referrals, and the monthly prescriptions. Price that year under the current plan and under the best alternative. The cheaper plan on paper is often not the cheaper plan in real life.
If your parent also owns a long-term care policy, keep it in the conversation. Medicare and long-term care insurance cover different things, and knowing where one stops and the other starts keeps you from planning around a gap that does not exist. If a move to a care community is on the horizon, it also helps to understand assisted living pricing, since Medicare will not be the line item that pays for daily support.
Step Four: Make Sure You're Allowed to Help
Here is the part that surprises adult children. A plan, or Medicare itself, may refuse to discuss your parent's account with you unless your parent has given permission. Sitting at the kitchen table helps. Calling on their behalf, without a signed authorization on file, often does not.
Set that up before you need it. A power of attorney handles the broader legal side. For Medicare specifically, ask 1-800-MEDICARE how to authorize a family member to speak with them.
You also do not have to decode this alone. Virginia's VICAP counselors offer free, unbiased Medicare help, and they are not paid by any insurer to steer your parent toward a particular plan. For families with a complicated picture, a geriatric care manager can also sit in on the review and keep the details straight.
Keep a Paper Trail
Whatever you decide, write it down. Save the Annual Notice of Change, note the date you made the decision, and keep any confirmation number the plan or Medicare.gov gives you. When the new card arrives in January, check it against what you chose, then store everything in your parent's emergency information folder so any family member can find it in a hurry.
The official Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov lets you enter your parent's drugs and pharmacy and compare plans side by side. Plans have been viewable there since October 1, so you can start before the window technically opens.
When Medicare Isn't the Whole Answer
Some families do this review and realize the plan is not the real problem. The real problem is that Dad is skipping doses, Mom is not eating well, and the person doing the paperwork is exhausted from being the whole care team.
At The Berkeley at Short Pump, we are a small, boutique community, which means the people helping your parent actually know your parent. That matters when the question is not just "which plan?" but "who notices when something changes?" Our assisted living and memory care residents get daily support with medications, meals, and routines, and their families get a team that picks up the phone.
If open enrollment has you wondering whether home is still the right setting, schedule a tour and see what a day here looks like. No pressure and no paperwork required.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What happens if my parent misses the deadline?
A: In most cases, they stay in their current coverage for all of 2027, including any changes the plan made. After December 7, switching generally requires a qualifying life event that opens a Special Enrollment Period. Medicare Advantage members get one limited extra chance, covered below.
Q: What's the difference between open enrollment and Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment?
A: Annual Enrollment (October 15 to December 7) is open to everyone with Medicare and allows nearly any change. Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment runs January 1 to March 31 and is only for people already in a Medicare Advantage plan. Those members get a single change, either to a different Advantage plan or back to Original Medicare.
Q: Can my parent switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare?
A: Yes, during Annual Enrollment or the Advantage Open Enrollment period. The catch is supplemental coverage. If your parent returns to Original Medicare and wants a Medigap policy, insurers in many cases can ask health questions and may charge more or decline. Check with a VICAP counselor about Virginia's rules before you drop the current plan.
Q: Does a move to a new care community change Medicare enrollment?
A: Moving alone does not usually reopen enrollment. A move outside your parent's plan service area typically does, because it can trigger a Special Enrollment Period. Even within the same area, confirm that the new address and the community's visiting providers still fit the plan's network.
Q: Does Medicare open enrollment also cover Affordable Care Act plans?
A: No. Medicare's window is separate from the ACA Marketplace, which has its own enrollment period beginning November 1. A person who has Medicare generally does not use the Marketplace for their health coverage.
Sources:
